Belay matches busy executives with U.S.-based assistants who work 9 to 5 in their own time zone, at a flat monthly rate it only quotes on a call. If you want something cheaper, a full-time person instead of 10 to 20 hours a week, or a price you can see before you book a meeting, the strongest alternative is to hire an executive assistant directly. HireTalent.ph is our pick for that: you search reviewed Filipino executive assistants, post a job for $48, and pay the person you hire with no markup.
If you'd rather not run your own hiring, this list also covers the managed services that compete with Belay head on. Every price comes from each company's own site, and where a company's pages disagree, we say so.
Here's the TLDR (prices checked November 17, 2026):
- HireTalent.ph (our pick): Best for a full-time Filipino executive assistant you hire and manage yourself. $48 per job post or $88/month, plus the salary you agree with the person.
- Boldly: Best for a premium U.S. or European assistant with a published price list. $2,600 to $6,500 a month for 40 to 100 hours.
- Time etc: Best for a few U.S.-based hours a week with no notice period. $390 to $2,160 a month for 10 to 60 hours.
- Prialto: Best for an office-based offshore assistant with trained backups and SOC 2. From $1,500 to $1,600 per 55-hour unit.
- Magic: Best for a full-time managed assistant from the Philippines or Latin America, billed weekly. $360 to $540 a week.
- Wing Assistant: Best for a managed full-time general VA at a published monthly price. $699 (80 hours) or $999 (160 hours) a month.
- Wishup: Best for a managed half-day or full-day assistant in India, or a US-based option at a premium. $1,299 to $5,400 a month.
Quick comparison
| Option | Model | Where the assistant is | Published price | Commitment |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| HireTalent.ph | Direct hire (you employ the contractor) | Philippines | $48/post or $88/mo, plus salary | None; cancel any time |
| Belay | Managed agency | U.S. | Not published for EAs | Month-to-month, 45 hrs/mo minimum |
| Boldly | Managed agency | U.S. or Europe | $65/hr ($2,600 for 40 hrs) | 30 days' notice, 40 hrs/mo minimum |
| Time etc | Managed agency | U.S. | $36 to $39/hr | No notice period |
| Prialto | Managed agency | Philippines, Kenya, Guatemala | $1,500 to $1,600 per 55 hrs | 90-day minimum per unit |
| Magic | Managed agency | Philippines, Latin America | $360 or $540/week, 40 hrs | No contract |
| Wing Assistant | Managed service | Worldwide | $699 or $999/mo | Month-to-month, 10 days' notice |
| Wishup | Managed agency | India (U.S. plan available) | $1,299 to $5,400/mo | Quarterly billing by default |
What Belay actually costs
Belay doesn't publish executive assistant pricing. Its FAQ describes "flexible, fractional engagements at a flat monthly rate" and says "BELAY isn't built to compete on rock-bottom price." The only numbers it prints are on its social media assistant page: "Starting at $2,070 / month" for 45 to 60 hours, and "Starting at $4,500 / month" for 60 to 100 hours. At the low end that works out to roughly $34.50 to $46 an hour.
Support "typically begins at 45 hours a month," runs month-to-month, and comes with a free rematch if the fit is wrong. Assistants are U.S.-based and work Monday to Friday, 9 to 5 in their own time zone. Belay's pages disagree on how they're engaged: its careers copy describes "1099 roles," while its competitor comparison page lists "Managed (W2)." Belay doesn't publish a fee for taking the assistant in-house.
1. HireTalent.ph (our pick)
HireTalent.ph is a hiring marketplace for Filipino professionals. You post a job or search profiles, interview, and hire directly as contractors. Every profile is reviewed by a person before it shows up in search, per the site, and you can filter for people who passed its timed tool certifications (14 are live, including ChatGPT, Claude AI, Microsoft Copilot and Zapier).
Pricing: the HireTalent.ph pricing page lists a Free plan where each job post costs $48, and an Employer plan at $88/month (or $880/year) with 3 job posts a month, cold outreach to 10 candidates a day and time tracking and payments for 3 people. Extra people cost $20/month each for time tracking, invoices and payments through Wise. There's no markup on the assistant's pay and no percentage of salary. If you don't want to screen, the done-for-you executive assistant search costs a one-time fee of 20% of first-year salary on hire, with a 90-day replacement.
What you'd pay the person: you set the rate. HireTalent.ph won't publish jobs below $5/hour or $600/month, per its fair salary commitment. For context, VirtualStaff.ph says most professional full-time roles there pay $500 to $1,200 a month, and Somewhere's pricing page shows example assistant salaries of $1,200 to $2,200.
Limits: you do the hiring. You write the post, screen, interview and manage the person, and the site's own comparison puts self-serve time-to-hire at "usually 4–6 weeks." On the Free plan you can only message people who applied to your post. There's no account manager, no backup assistant and no replacement guarantee unless you pay for the recruiting service. Hires are contractors, so there's no payroll, benefits or tax withholding. The Philippines is 12 to 13 hours ahead of US Eastern, so live overlap during your day means a night shift for the assistant. If that's a dealbreaker, HireTalent.lat works the same way, at the same prices, with Latin American talent closer to US hours. Both sites also have very few third-party reviews so far.
Pick it if: you want one full-time EA who works only for you, at a fraction of agency rates, and you're willing to spend a few weeks hiring. Our HireTalent.ph review covers the platform in more depth.
2. Boldly
Boldly is the closest like-for-like Belay alternative: a premium subscription with a dedicated, experienced assistant, but with a price list you can read. Staff are based in North America or Europe, and "Our US team are employees, rather than contractors," per its pricing page.
Pricing: $2,600 a month for 40 hours, $3,900 for 60, $5,200 for 80 and $6,500 for 100, which is $65 an hour on every plan. Paying by card adds 2.9%. Up to 160 hours is "Ask us for pricing." There's no startup fee, you meet the assistant before you subscribe, and a trained backup covers vacations and sick days.
Limits: hours are billed in advance, and unused hours don't roll over or get refunded. Cancelling needs 30 days' written notice. Its terms include a 12-month non-solicit, and hiring your assistant directly is only allowed at Boldly's discretion after 6 months, for 6 times the largest monthly fee with a $30,000 minimum.
Pick it if: you want Belay-level service with a published price and you're comfortable at $65 an hour. If Boldly is the one you were leaning toward, we cover alternatives to Boldly separately.
3. Time etc
Time etc sells monthly hour bundles with a dedicated U.S.-based assistant, matched for you after a consultation. It's built for small, steady workloads rather than a full-time hire.
Pricing: per its plans page, $390/month for 10 hours, $760 for 20, $1,480 for 40 and $2,160 for 60 ($39 down to $36 an hour). There's no setup fee and "no notice period," and your first task is free with no card. Unused hours roll over on the 20-hour plans and up (the 10-hour card doesn't list rollover, while the FAQ says hours roll over, so ask).
Limits: the biggest published plan is 60 hours a month, so it isn't a full-time option. You don't choose the assistant, and extra-hour pricing isn't published.
Pick it if: you need 5 to 15 hours a week of U.S.-based help and want to cancel with one email.
4. Prialto
Prialto employs its assistants full-time in its own offices in the Philippines, Kenya and Guatemala, adds an Engagement Manager, and keeps "two fully trained backup assistants" ready if yours is out or leaves. Hours are 9am to 6pm on weekdays.
Pricing: Prialto sells 55-hour monthly units. Its pricing page shows $1,600 per unit in one place and $1,500 in another, and its FAQ says pricing "starts at $1,500 per month," so expect $1,500 to $1,600. A full-time dedicated assistant (165+ hours) starts at $3,600/month. There's a 90-day minimum per unit and a $250 setup fee, waived on a one-year agreement.
Limits: you can't choose or interview your assistant, and there's no published path to hire them yourself. The 90-day minimum is stricter than Belay's month-to-month.
Pick it if: you want offshore pricing with agency-style continuity, and security reviews matter (the site says it holds SOC 2 Type 2).
5. Magic
Magic hires, trains and pays a full-time dedicated assistant in the Philippines or Latin America and bills you weekly. You meet the assistant Magic picks and decide whether to go ahead.
Pricing: per its pricing page, a Virtual Assistant is $360/week and an Executive Assistant is $540/week, both for 40 hours, on four-week billing ($1,440 or $2,160 every four weeks). That's about $9 and $13.50 an hour. The EA plan includes "Magic 24/7," where another assistant covers urgent work while yours is offline. No contracts, cancel any time, and you only pay once you've chosen your assistant. Part-time plans exist but aren't priced publicly.
Limits: Magic doesn't publish what the assistant is paid, so you can't see the markup, and there are no published terms for hiring the assistant directly.
Pick it if: you want a full-time offshore EA with management and cover built in, and weekly billing suits you.
6. Wing Assistant
Wing sells a dedicated general virtual assistant on a flat monthly subscription, with a Customer Success Manager and replacement "within 24 hours." Its FAQ says assistants are "based all over the world." Our Wing Assistant review goes through the terms in detail.
Pricing: $699/month for 80 hours or $999/month for 160 hours, per its pricing section. Card payments add $35/month. Its terms describe a non-refundable deposit (amount not published) and say all fees are non-refundable. It's month-to-month with 10 days' notice before renewal.
Limits: prices are published only for a general VA, not an executive assistant. Wing's terms say Wing "does not employ, engage, or manage these Assistants," which sits oddly with its managed pitch, and after you cancel the assistant is reassigned to other clients.
Pick it if: you want the cheapest published managed full-time option and your work is general admin rather than C-suite support.
7. Wishup
Wishup is a managed service with a dedicated assistant plus a VA manager. Standard assistants are in India and work a night shift to cover US hours; a separate plan offers US-based assistants.
Pricing: its pricing page shows Prime VA at $1,299/month (4 hours) or $1,999 (8 hours), Elite at $1,999 or $2,999, and US-based VA at $3,000 or $5,400. The page doesn't say whether "4 hours" and "8 hours" mean per day, so confirm. Billing defaults to quarterly, and payment gateway fees aren't included.
Limits: no money-back or buyout terms are published, and the page doesn't say whether quarterly billing means a quarterly commitment.
Pick it if: you want a managed half-day assistant at a published price and don't need the Philippines or Latin America specifically.
Full-time cost, year one
A rough guide from published prices only; hours differ by plan. For HireTalent.ph we assumed a $1,000 monthly salary (you set the real number).
| Option | What you get | Year-one cost |
|---|---|---|
| HireTalent.ph | Full-time EA you hire, $1,000/mo salary + one $48 post + a $20/mo payments seat | About $12,288 |
| Wing Assistant | 160 hrs/mo general VA, paying by bank transfer | $11,988 |
| Wishup | Prime VA, 8-hour plan | $23,988 |
| Time etc | 60 hrs/mo (not full-time) | $25,920 |
| Magic | Executive Assistant, 40 hrs/week | $28,080 |
| Prialto | Full-time dedicated assistant, from | $43,200 |
| Boldly | 100 hrs/mo (not full-time) | $78,000 |
| Belay | Not published for EAs | Quote only |
How to choose
- Decide whether you'll do the hiring. If you can spend a few weeks interviewing, hiring directly costs a fraction of any agency. If you can't, pay an agency to choose for you. Our roundup of virtual assistant companies sorts the field by that split.
- Decide on hours. Belay, Boldly and Time etc are built around 10 to 25 hours a week. If the role is full-time, a direct hire, Magic, Prialto or Wing fits better.
- Decide on time zone. Live coverage across your US day points to Belay, Boldly, Time etc or a Latin American hire, since a Filipino EA covering your day works nights. Our guide to hiring an EA in Colombia or Mexico covers that route.
- Read the exit terms. Ask how you'd hire the assistant yourself later. Boldly's minimum is $30,000; most others don't publish a number.
FAQ
How much does Belay cost?
Belay doesn't publish executive assistant prices; you get a quote after a call. Its social media assistant page starts at $2,070 a month for 45 to 60 hours and $4,500 a month for 60 to 100 hours, and support typically starts at 45 hours a month.
What is a cheaper alternative to Belay?
Hiring a Filipino executive assistant directly is the cheapest route with a full-time person. On HireTalent.ph a job post is $48 and you pay the assistant's salary with no markup. Among managed services with published prices, Wing Assistant ($999 a month for 160 hours) and Magic ($540 a week for a full-time EA) cost far less than U.S.-based agencies.
Are Belay assistants employees or contractors?
Belay's own pages disagree. Its careers copy describes "1099 roles" and its llms.txt says services are "contractor-staffed," while its competitor comparison page lists "Managed (W2)." Ask Belay directly if it matters to you.
Can I hire my Belay assistant directly?
Belay says it "can help you transition your Executive Assistant into an internal full-time role," but it doesn't publish a fee. Get the number in writing before you start. By comparison, Boldly's terms set a minimum of $30,000.
What's the difference between Belay and Boldly?
Both sell experienced, part-time assistants on monthly plans. Boldly publishes its prices ($65 an hour, from $2,600 for 40 hours), offers U.S. or European staff and lets you meet the assistant before paying. Belay is U.S.-only and quotes on a call.
Is a Filipino executive assistant a good replacement for Belay?
For most admin, inbox, calendar and research work, yes, if you're comfortable managing them and can work around the time difference. Our list of the best sites to hire Filipino virtual assistants compares where to find them, and the VA salary guide covers pay ranges.
If budget is the reason you're leaving Belay, start by posting one EA job on HireTalent.ph and see who applies before you sign another agency plan.